MLB Best Bets for September 17, 2026

Athletics vs. Tampa Bay Rays

Event: Thu, Sep 17 · 1:10 PM EDT

Odd$mith pick: Athletics +1.5 (100)

Result: Loss · Athletics 1, Tampa Bay Rays 10

Featured analysis: Athletics +1.5: A Low‑Risk Gold Mine

The A’s have the firepower to keep it tight, making the +1.5 spread a cheap cocktail for bettors.

Open match page Read analysis

San Diego Padres vs. Colorado Rockies

Event: Thu, Sep 17 · 3:10 PM EDT

Odd$mith pick: Under 11.0 (-118)

Result: Push · San Diego Padres 9, Colorado Rockies 2

Open match page

Kansas City Royals vs. Houston Astros

Event: Thu, Sep 17 · 7:16 PM EDT

Odd$mith pick: Over 9.0 (-108)

Result: Loss · Kansas City Royals 2, Houston Astros 6

Open match page

Philadelphia Phillies vs. New York Mets

Event: Thu, Sep 17 · 7:16 PM EDT

Odd$mith pick: Philadelphia Phillies ML (114)

Result: Win · Philadelphia Phillies 3, New York Mets 0

Open match page

Boston Red Sox vs. Texas Rangers

Event: Thu, Sep 17 · 8:06 PM EDT

Odd$mith pick: Texas Rangers ML (118)

Result: Loss · Boston Red Sox 4, Texas Rangers 3

Open match page