MLS match page

Columbus Crew SC vs. New York City FC

Game time: May 10, 2026 4:30 PM EDT

Team snapshot

Columbus Crew SC

Record: 13-5-15

New York City FC

Record: 9-12-12

Full picks for this match

Columbus Crew SC vs. New York City FC

Moneyline: New York City FC ML (150) — Win

EV signal: Premium only

CLV: 0.0% vs closing line

Final score: Columbus Crew SC 0, New York City FC 3

Why this play: New York City FC’s balanced attack and disciplined defense make them the sharper choice on the road against a Columbus Crew side that has struggled to find consistency.

Quick read:

Columbus Crew SC enters this matchup with some question marks in their lineup, particularly in maintaining defensive solidity against dynamic offenses. Their home advantage is a factor, but it might not be enough to contain a New York City FC squad known for its tactical flexibility and ability to adapt on the fly.

New York City FC’s approach typically involves controlling the midfield and exploiting spaces with quick transitions, which could expose the Crew’s occasional lapses in coverage. On the road, NYCFC has shown resilience and a knack for grinding out results, making their moneyline an appealing wager.

While Columbus will push hard to capitalize on their home turf, New York City FC’s balanced roster and strategic discipline give them the upper hand in securing the win outright.

Log this pick

Archive note

Archived match pages skip live props to reduce API calls and keep history pages lighter.

Odd$mith app

📱 Every pick, in your pocket. Daily best-bet cards, live odds, and the full board — free on Android. Get the app →