Prediction: New York Mets VS Philadelphia Phillies 2025-06-20

The Phillies vs. Mets: A Tale of Two Teams, One Glorious Rivalry
The NL East’s most bitter feud (yes, even more than the Yankees-Red Sox) kicks off this weekend as the Phillies (45-30) host the Mets (45-30) in a three-game series. Both teams are tied for the division lead, but the stakes are clear: revenge for the Phillies after being swept by the Mets earlier this season, and redemption for the Mets, who’ve stumbled through a week-long slump. Let’s break it down with the precision of a scout and the wit of a late-night host.

---

### The Numbers Game
- Phillies:
- 40-22 when favored on the moneyline (64.5% win rate).
- 3.87 ERA (14th in MLB).
- Zack Wheeler (7-2, 2.76 ERA) returns to Citizens Bank Park, where he’s 4-1 with a 2.89 ERA this season.

- Mets:
- 42.9% win rate as underdogs (slightly below baseball’s 41% underdog average).
- 3.06 ERA (lowest in MLB).
- Juan Soto (.248, 23 HRs) and Pete Alonso (.291, 17 HRs) form a lethal 1-2 punch.

Key Matchup: Wheeler vs. Taijuan Walker (6-4, 3.52 ERA). Wheeler’s 2.76 ERA vs. the Mets this season? A cool 2.00. The Mets’ offense, meanwhile, has scored just 3.8 runs per game in their last 10.

---

### Injuries & Absences
- Phillies: No major injuries. Kyle Schwarber (.241, 23 HRs) is healthy and hungry for revenge after being swept in April.
- Mets: Star shortstop Francisco Lindor is day-to-day with a minor hamstring tweak, but the rest of the roster is intact.

---

### Odds & EV Calculations
The lines are all over the place, but here’s the consensus:
- Moneyline: Phillies -140, Mets +260.
- Spread: Phillies -1.5 (-140), Mets +1.5 (+120).
- Total: 8.5 runs (Over -110, Under -110).

Expected Value (EV) Breakdown:
1. Mets Moneyline (+260):
- Implied probability: 27.8%.
- Adjusted for baseball’s 41% underdog win rate: 34.4% (split the difference).
- EV: (34.4% * 2.69) - (65.6% * 1) = +26.9%.

2. Phillies Moneyline (-140):
- Implied probability: 58.3%.
- Adjusted for their 64.5% win rate when favored: 61.4%.
- EV: (61.4% * 1.47) - (38.6% * 1) = +26.1%.

3. Spread (Mets +1.5):
- Implied probability: 52.6% (from +120 line).
- Historical underdog cover rate in MLB: ~38%.
- EV: (38% * 2.0) - (62% * 1) = +14%.

4. Total (Under 8.5):
- Combined ERAs: 3.87 (Phillies) + 3.06 (Mets) = 6.93.
- Projected runs: ~6.93.
- Bet the Under (-110) for a safe, low-risk play.

---

### The Verdict
While the Phillies are the chalk, the Mets +260 offer the best expected value. Their 3.06 ERA and lethal offense (Soto/Alonso) make them a dangerous underdog, especially against a Phillies staff that’s ranked just 14th in ERA. Plus, history favors the Mets in this rivalry—they’ve won 5 of their last 7 meetings, including a sweep in April.

Best Bet: New York Mets Moneyline (+260).
Alternative: Under 8.5 Runs (-110).

Final Thought: The Phillies want revenge, but the Mets want respect. And right now, the numbers say the Mets are the better bet. As the great Yogi Berra once said, “It ain’t over till it’s over.” But it is over for the Phillies if they don’t stop letting the Mets win.

Stream it all on Apple TV+ (Friday) and ESPN/FOX (Weekend). Don’t miss the drama—and don’t bet your house on this. We’re not that confident. 🎬

More archived MLB predictions

Original social copy