Legacy Prediction

Prediction: Philadelphia Phillies VS Oakland Athletics 2025-05-23

Published May 23, 2025, 12:54 p.m. · MLB

Archived page: this prediction was originally published for a past matchup/date. It stays live as part of the Odd$mith archive.

Current analysis Today’s Best Bets Current MLB

Prediction:  Philadelphia Phillies VS Oakland Athletics 2025-05-23

The Philadelphia Phillies, with their impressive 32-18 record, are set to take on the Oakland Athletics, who are struggling at 22-29. The Phillies are -181 favorites, while the Athletics are +150 underdogs. With Zack Wheeler on the mound for the Phillies and Jeffrey Springs for the Athletics, this matchup is shaping up to be a thrilling one.

The Phillies have been on fire, averaging 4.9 runs per game, which is the sixth-highest in the majors. They also have a strong record when favored on the moneyline, with a 27-14 record in those games. On the other hand, the Athletics have struggled as underdogs and have a combined ERA of 5.34, which is not ideal when facing a team like the Phillies.

Key players to watch for the Phillies include Kyle Schwarber, Bryce Harper, and Trea Turner, who have been instrumental in their team's success. For the Athletics, Jacob Wilson, Tyler Soderstrom, and Brent Rooker will need to step up if they want to take down the Phillies.

My best bet for this game is the Philadelphia Phillies -1.5 runs. With their strong offense and Wheeler on the mound, I think they have a good chance of covering the spread. The Athletics' high ERA and struggles as underdogs also make me lean towards the Phillies. Take the Phillies -1.5 runs at -1.83 odds.

As for the total, I think the under 9.5 runs is a good bet. The Phillies have a decent team ERA, and Wheeler is a solid pitcher. The Athletics' offense has been inconsistent, and I think they might struggle to score against the Phillies. Take the under 9.5 runs at 1.83 odds.

In summary, my predictions are:

Philadelphia Phillies -1.5 runs at -1.83 odds
Under 9.5 runs at 1.83 odds

Let's see how the game plays out!

More archived MLB predictions

Prediction: San Diego Padres VS Los Angeles Angels 2026-04-18

April 18, 2026, 10:48 p.m. · Prediction: Los Angeles Angels 6, San Diego Padres 5 Outcome: San Diego Padres 4, Los Angeles Angels 1 Score: Padres 4,…

Prediction: Los Angeles Dodgers VS Colorado Rockies 2026-04-18

April 18, 2026, 7:18 p.m. · Prediction: Dodgers 7, Rockies 3 Outcome: Rockies 4, Dodgers 3 Score: Rockies 4, Dodgers 3 Result: Lose

Prediction: Toronto Blue Jays VS Arizona Diamondbacks 2026-04-18

April 18, 2026, 7:15 p.m. · Prediction: Arizona 4, Toronto 2 Outcome: Arizona 6, Toronto 2 Score: 6-2 Win/Lose: Win

Prediction: New York Mets VS Chicago Cubs 2026-04-18

April 18, 2026, 12:16 p.m. · Prediction: Cubs Outcome: Cubs won 4-2 Score: Cubs 4, Mets 2 Result: Win

Prediction: Kansas City Royals VS New York Yankees 2026-04-18

April 18, 2026, 6:49 a.m. · Prediction: Yankees Outcome: Yankees won 13-4 Score: Yankees 13, Royals 4 Win/Lose: Win

Odd$mith app

📱 Every pick, in your pocket. Daily best-bet cards, live odds, and the full board — free on Android. Get the app →