Prediction: Phoenix Mercury VS New York Liberty 2025-09-17

New York Liberty vs. Phoenix Mercury: A Tale of Twists, Tumbles, and Triple-Doubles

Parse the Odds: The Numbers Don’t Lie (Mostly)
The New York Liberty, defending WNBA champs, are the -155 favorites to close out the Mercury in Game 2, while Phoenix sits at +255, offering tempting value for those who think “sweep” is overrated. The implied probabilities? Liberty at ~61% (155/(155+100)) to win, Mercury at ~28% (100/(255+100)). But let’s not let math be the only narrator here. The Liberty’s home-court advantage is no mere coincidence—they’re a dominant 17-5 at home with a +12.1 net rating, which is basically the WNBA’s version of a “force field.” The Mercury, meanwhile, are 12-10 on the road, which is solid but not exactly the resume of a team ready to pull off an underdog heist.

The total is set at 159.5 points, with nearly every bookie offering even money on Over/Under. That’s a hint: expect a high-octane Game 2, unless both teams decide to play chess with a basketball.

Digest the News: Injuries, Triple-Doubles, and a Dash of Drama
Here’s the plot twist: Breanna Stewart, the Liberty’s Swiss Army knife, is listed as questionable with a right-knee injury. She didn’t practice Tuesday and may be a game-time decision. Stewart’s absence would be like ordering a five-star meal and getting a side of croutons—still edible, but not what you paid for. Without her, the Liberty’s offense could resemble a GPS recalculating after a wrong turn.

On the Mercury’s side? They’re banking on the “home-court advantage” of… well, not home. They’ll try to force a Game 3 in Phoenix, where they’re 7-3 this season. But let’s not forget: Game 1 was a 76-69 overtime thriller, and the Mercury let a late lead slip away. Coach Sandy Brondello called Stewart’s injury “not serious,” but in sports, “not serious” often means “she’ll play if the universe aligns and the team’s Twitter account doesn’t crash.”

Alyssa Thomas, the Liberty’s workhorse, is a -128 favorite to go OVER 33.5 combined stats. That’s the WNBA’s version of a “walking triple-double.” Meanwhile, Sabrina Ionescu is an underdog to stay UNDER 18.5 points. If she does, it’ll be the first time this season she’s hit a points cap since 2019. Bet on Thomas for the triple-double; bet on Ionescu to prove the oddsmakers wrong—unless you’re superstitious, in which case, don’t mention the “C” word (choking).

Humorous Spin: Basketball, But Make It Absurd
The Liberty’s defense without Stewart? Imagine a castle with the drawbridge up and the moat dried up. The Mercury, on the other hand, are like a soap opera villain plotting their comeback: “You think this is over? Game 1 was just the prologue, darling.”

As for the total points, 159.5 is basically the WNBA’s version of a “suggested retail price.” These teams will either blow by it like a Tesla on a country road or huddle up like accountants auditing a budget. And let’s not forget the Liberty’s +12.1 net rating at home—it’s like they’ve got a “Do Not Disturb” sign for the Mercury’s offense.

Prediction: The Verdict (and a Few Jokes at the Expense of Socks)
Here’s the bottom line: The Liberty are favorites for a reason. They’ve got the home crowd, the championship pedigree, and a net rating that could double as a superhero’s power. But Breanna Stewart’s absence? That’s the plot hole in their armor. Phoenix, with its “we’re not going down without a fight” energy, has the tools to pull the upset—especially if the Liberty’s bench (Burke, Sabally, Harrison) plays like a group of interns on their first day.

So, what’s the call? Phoenix Mercury +4.5 to force Game 3, with the Over 159.5 points as a safety net. The Liberty’s offense will sputter without Stewart, and the Mercury’s “let it rip” mentality will keep the score inflated. As for Breanna? Let’s hope her knee isn’t as dramatic as her Game 1 exit—no one wants to see her trip over her own shoelaces again.

Final line: Bet Phoenix +255 and Over 159.5. If you’re feeling spicy, throw in a prop bet that Stewart’s sock color mismatches. You’ll win that one for sure. 🏀🔥

More archived WNBA predictions

Original social copy