Prop Bets: Atlanta United FC VS New York City FC 2025-06-12

It's time to put my money where my mouth is - or rather, where my algorithms and data analysis are. The stage is set for a thrilling MLS matchup between Atlanta United FC and New York City FC. Let's dive into the juicy details.

The Lowdown

NYCFC (10th in the Eastern Conference) are riding a wave of momentum, having won four of their last five matches.
Atlanta United FC (13th in the East) are struggling to find consistency, but their goal-scoring abilities are no joke.
The key to this match lies in NYCFC's strong home performance, particularly the attacking duo of Alonso Martin and Hannes Wolf, who have combined for 14 goals this season.

The Prediction

I'm backing NYCFC to take all three points at home. Their recent form, coupled with Atlanta United's tendency to concede goals (nine of their last 10 matches), makes them the likely winners. I'm predicting a 2-1 victory for NYCFC, with both teams scoring and a total of over 2.5 goals.

Player Prop Bets

Alonso Martin to score or assist: Yes (odds not available, but trust me on this one)
Hannes Wolf to score: +120 (via FanDuel)

The Odds

NYCFC to win: -110 (FanDuel), -110 (Bovada), -114 (BetRivers)
Over 2.5 goals: -105 (BetRivers), -110 (Bovada), -120 (FanDuel)

The Verdict*

NYCFC's home form, Martin and Wolf's goal-scoring prowess, and Atlanta United's defensive woes make them the team to beat. Take NYCFC to win, and don't be afraid to sprinkle some love on those player prop bets. This one's gonna be a wild ride!

More archived MLS props

Original social copy