Prop Bets: Baltimore Orioles VS San Francisco Giants 2025-08-31

Giants vs. Orioles: A Tale of Two Teams (and One Very Tired Justin Verlander)

The San Francisco Giants (-133) are favored to stomp the Baltimore Orioles (+110) on Sunday, but let’s be honest: this game might hinge on whether Justin Verlander can remember how to throw a baseball. The 41-year-old Verlander, who’s posted a 4.47 ERA this season while striking out 104 batters in 116⅔ innings, will start for the Giants. Meanwhile, the Orioles counter with Tomoyuki Sugano (10-6, 3.72 ERA), who’s quietly been one of the better starters in this matchup.

Why the Giants Should Win (Probably):
- Pitching? What Pitching? The Orioles’ 26th-ranked ERA (4.72) will face a Giants lineup that’s somehow 13th in runs scored (4.2 RPG). Verlander’s 57.1% implied win probability (based on -133 odds) might be generous, but at least he’s not completely lost his touch… yet.
- Offense Overload? The Giants’ 24th-ranked offense (4.2 RPG) will try to capitalize on Baltimore’s 26th-ranked pitching staff. Rafael Devers (.260, 27 HRs) and Heliot Ramos (.265, 16 HRs) are the only real threats, but even they’ll need help.

Why the Orioles Should Win (Ha!):
- Miracles Happen! The Orioles (+110) are 43-75 as underdogs this season, but hey, maybe they’ll finally break through. Their 5.8 RPG average (18th) could theoretically outslug the Giants’ 4.2, but only if Sugano doesn’t serve up 10 home runs.
- Prop Bets to Watch:
- Gunnar Henderson (-110, Over 0.5 HRs): The Orioles’ slugger has a .224 ISO (isolated power) this season—good for a 33% chance to go deep.
- Verlander’s Strikeouts (Under 5.5, -110): With a 5.5 K/9 this season, Verlander’s likely to flirt with the 5.5 mark. Take the Under.
- Over 8.5 Runs (-105): The Giants’ games have gone Over 7.5 runs 61% of the time, while the Orioles’ games have gone Over 58%. This feels like a 9-run fest waiting to happen.

Final Prediction:
The Giants win 5-3, Verlander finally retires after the game, and the Orioles’ bullpen somehow blows a 2-run lead in the 9th. Take the Giants (-1.5) and the Over 8.5 runs. And for the love of baseball, send Verlander to a spa.

Implied probabilities: Giants 57.1%, Orioles 42.9%. The line is a gift to the Orioles, but they’ll need a miracle—and a better starting pitcher. 🎩⚾

More archived MLB props

Original social copy