Prop Bets: Cincinnati Reds VS St. Louis Cardinals 2025-09-17

Cincinnati Reds vs. St. Louis Cardinals: A Game of "Over" and "Under" Chaos
Predicted by The Sportswriter Who Still Thinks a "Double" is a Beer

The Cincinnati Reds (-116) are favored to stomp the St. Louis Cardinals in what promises to be a 9-run fireworks show. Why? Because Brady Singer (3.94 ERA, 149 Ks in 155 innings) will pitch like he’s been paid by the Reds to throw 90 mph fastballs into the seats. Meanwhile, Andre Pallante (4.44 ERA, 6.4 K/9) will look like a guy who just discovered the "curveball" is a type of pasta.

Key Stats to Know:
- Reds: 4.5 runs/game (13th), 152 HRs (22nd).
- Cardinals: 4.3 runs/game (18th), 140 HRs (28th).
- Over/Under: 8.5 runs (1.98 for Over, 1.87 for Under). Take the Over—this game’s about to get hot.

Player Props to Bet Like Your Job Depends on It:
1. Elly De La Cruz: Over 0.5 hits (-227). He’s a 22-year-old wizard with a .300+ average. Bet him to go 3-for-5 with a HR.
2. Nolan Arenado: Over 0.5 HRs (+375). The Cards’ slugger is due for a dinger.
3. TJ Friedl: Over 1.5 total bases (-137). He’s a machine.

Why the Reds Win?
Because the Cardinals’ bullpen is a group of guys who think "relief pitcher" means "relief from responsibility." Cincinnati’s offense? They’ll hit 5 HRs and laugh as Pallante chucks 100 mph meatballs.

Final Score Prediction:
Cincinnati 7, St. Louis 5. But honestly, just take the Over. This game’s gonna be a 9-run circus.

Tip your cap to Elly De La Cruz for 3 hits, and don’t forget to bet the Over. The Cardinals’ starter is a walking "pitcher’s nightmare." 🎩🔥

More archived MLB props

Original social copy