Prop Bets: Colorado Rockies VS Cincinnati Reds 2025-07-13

Cincinnati Reds vs. Colorado Rockies Prediction: A Humble Victory for the Reds

The Cincinnati Reds (-243) are heavy favorites against the cellar-dwelling Rockies (22-72, .230 team BA), and for good reason. With Nick Martinez (4.50 ERA) on the mound and a lineup that averages 4.6 runs per game, the Reds should exploit the Rockies’ porous defense and shaky pitching. Austin Gomber (5.10 ERA) starts for Colorado, and his control issues could spell trouble for a Rockies team that’s scored just 3.8 runs per game.

Key Player Props to Watch:
- Elly De La Cruz (Reds): Over 1.5 hits (-140) — His speed and contact make this a lock.
- Spencer Steer (Reds): Over 1.5 RBIs (-130) — With Martinez’s power, he’ll drive in runs.
- Ryan McMahon (Rockies): Under 0.5 HRs (-172) — The Rockies’ offense isn’t built for power.

Why the Reds Win:
- Martinez’s 4.50 ERA is misleading; his 6.12 FIP suggests regression is coming.
- The Rockies’ .230 team BA can’t scratch runs against a Reds bullpen with a 3.85 ERA.
- High implied total (9.5) is inflated; under is a safer play.

Final Pick: Cincinnati Reds to win outright (-1.5 runs) and Under 9.5 total runs (-110).

“The Rockies’ offense is so anemic, they’d need a lunar eclipse to score 5 runs. Stick with the Reds.” — Your Humble Handicapper 🎩

More archived MLB props

Original social copy