Prop Bets: New York Mets VS Cincinnati Reds 2025-09-07

Reds vs. Mets: A Tale of Two Teams (and a Lot of Injuries)
The Cincinnati Reds (-123) host the New York Mets (+110) in a September showdown where neither squad is exactly healthy. Let’s break it down with the precision of a MLB closer’s slider:

The Goods
- Moneyline: Reds are -123 favorites, implying a 55.2% win chance. The Mets (+110) need a miracle, a 12-game hitting streak from Brandon Nimmo (who’s riding a 27-game heater), or a sudden surge from their 15-player IL.
- Total: 8.5 runs (Over: 1.87, Under: 1.95). With the Reds’ 24th-ranked strikeout rate (24%) and Hunter Greene’s 6.5 K prop line (-130 to hit 6.5+ Ks), expect a pitcher’s duel… until someone forgets their fastball.

Key Props to Bet
- Pete Alonso (MITS 1.5, -190): The “King of the Long Ball” is 1.5 hits away from a free t-shirt. Bet against it.
- Elly De La Cruz (Doubles Over 0.5, -430): The Reds’ 5-tool marvel is a lock to double. Or maybe not—his IL odds are rising.
- Greene’s Strikeouts (Over 6.5, -130): The Reds’ ace has a 2.70 ERA, but his 10.1 K/9 rate says “Over” in cursive.

Why the Mets Might Win
Because Brandon Nimmo is due for a slump, and the Reds’ IL includes 9 starters. But realistically? The Reds’ 3.96 ERA vs. the Mets’ 3.92 ERA means this could hinge on who trips over their own spikes first.

Final Prediction
The Reds win 4-3 in 10 innings after a walk-off single by… checks notes… someone not on the active roster. Bet the Under, but only if you enjoy heartburn.

“Baseball: Where 26 men try to outguess each other while 9 others nap in the dugout.”

More archived MLB props

Original social copy