Prop Bets: New York Yankees VS Cincinnati Reds 2025-06-24

"Yankees vs. Reds: When Your Starter’s Worse Than a Pop Song in 2025"

The New York Yankees (45-32) roll into Cincinnati to face the Reds (40-38) on June 24, 2025, armed with a 1.5-run spread advantage and a starting pitcher, Allan Winans, who’s about as reliable as a TikTok trend. The Reds, meanwhile, counter with Nick Lodolo, a pitcher who’s basically the anti-Winans, fresh off a 4-1 win over the Cardinals.

The Odds:
- Moneyline: Yankees -1.6 (favorites), Reds +2.4 (underdogs).
- Spread: Yankees -1.5 (-110), Reds +1.5 (-110).
- Total: 9.5 runs (Over +183, Under -233).

Why the Reds Might Win This With a Straight Face:
Lodolo (4.20 ERA, 1.25 WHIP) has the stuff of a guy who’d probably win a “Most Likely to Be a Barista” contest—consistent, unshowy, and not prone to spilling coffee (i.e., giving up runs). The Yankees? They’re starting Winans, who’s authored a 5.85 ERA and a 1.55 WHIP this season. Fun fact: Winans’ ERA is higher than the Reds’ team batting average (.252).

The Under Is a Safe Bet for Grandma:
With both teams’ offenses resembling a slow-motion car crash (Yankees: .238 team BA, Reds: .245), the UNDER 9.5 runs (-233) is as safe as a vault in a world of Bitcoin memes. The Reds have hit the UNDER in 5 of their last 7 games; the Yankees? They’ve hit the UNDER exactly once in their last 10.

Prediction:
The Reds will win 3-2 in 10 innings, with Lodolo looking like a $100 million draft pick and Winans looking like he forgot his own pitch count. The Yankees’ offense will muster exactly one hit, a double by Aaron Judge that’s ruled a ground rule single because the umpire was distracted by a squirrel.

Final Score: Reds 3, Yankees 2.
How It Happens: The UNDER cashes, the Reds cover the 1.5-run spread, and the Yankees’ GM starts drafting a press release for next year’s “Rebuild 2026: Electric Boogaloo.”

Place your bets before the Yankees’ lineup becomes a case study in why you never trust a pitcher named “Allan.” 🎲⚾

More archived MLB props

Original social copy