Prop Bets: Pittsburgh Pirates VS St. Louis Cardinals 2025-08-27

Pirates vs. Cardinals: A Tale of Two Teams (and a Few Doubles)
August 27, 2025 | 11:46 PM ET

The Pittsburgh Pirates, fresh off a 5-1 series win against the Cardinals, are here to rub salt in the wound. Or maybe just to salt the game? Either way, they’re the underdogs (+245) with a 1.5-run spread in their favor (-165). The Cardinals, led by Sonny Gray (12-6, 4.33 ERA), are the favorites (-315), but let’s be real—they’ve been so bad this season (65-67) that “favorite” feels like a stretch.

Why the Pirates Might Win (and Why You Should Bet on Bryan Reynolds’ Doubles):
- Reynolds’ Power: Bryan Reynolds is a doubles machine. At +390 for Over 0.5 doubles, he’s practically guaranteed to double… or at least trip.
- Mlodzinski’s Struggles: Pirates starter Carmen Mlodzinski (3-7, 3.89 ERA) has allowed 3+ runs in 4 of his last 5 starts. He’s the MLB version of a leaky faucet—ineffective but not catastrophic.
- Pirates’ Recent Firepower: They’ve scored 8 runs in their last game. If they keep this up, the Over 7.5 (-110) might be a lock.

Why the Cardinals Might Win (Spoiler: They Probably Won’t):
- Sonny Gray’s Clutch: Gray (2-1, 2.45 in 3 career vs. Pirates) has a 2.45 ERA in three career starts against Pittsburgh. But let’s not forget, this is baseball—anything can happen, like a pitcher suddenly developing a third arm.
- Defensive Depth: The Cardinals have the 10th-best team ERA (3.98) vs. the Pirates’ 4.72. But defense doesn’t matter when you’re down 8-0.

Player Props to Watch:
- Bryan Reynolds: Over 0.5 doubles (+390) – Because why not?
- Sonny Gray: Under 6.5 strikeouts (-149) – He’s more of a “touch ’em all” guy.
- Alec Burleson: Over 0.5 doubles (+400) – Double or nothing?

Final Prediction:
The Pirates (+1.5) will win 8-5, fueled by Reynolds’ doubles and a Cardinals bullpen that implodes faster than a soufflé in a hurricane. Take the Over 7.5 runs and laugh all the way to the bank.

Final Score: Pirates 8, Cardinals 5.
Key Prop Win: Bryan Reynolds doubles. Twice.

Disclaimer: This prediction is not financial advice. But if you bet on Reynolds’ doubles, you’re basically guaranteed to win… or at least feel smug. 🎲⚾

More archived MLB props

Original social copy