Prop Bets: St. Louis Cardinals VS Cincinnati Reds 2025-08-30

The Reds vs. Cardinals Showdown: A Statistical Circus in Cincinnati

The Cincinnati Reds (-152) and St. Louis Cardinals (+127) clash in a game that’s less a baseball match and more of a statistical juggling act. The Reds, fresh off a 30-27 record as favorites this season, are favored to avoid another three-game losing streak. The Cardinals, meanwhile, are 47.2% winners as underdogs but haven’t exactly been the underdog version of a tank in the standings.

Pitcher Props: A Tale of Two ERAs
Starting pitchers Andrew Abbott (8-4, 2.62 ERA) and Michael McGreevy (5-2, 4.28 ERA) face off in a battle of wits and… well, ERAs. Abbott’s implied total for strikeouts is 5.5 (FanDuel has him at +105 to exceed that), while McGreevy is projected for 3.5 Ks (-105). If you’re feeling spicy, bet on the Under 8.5 runs total (-110) — because nothing says “thrilling game” like a pitcher’s duel.

Hitter Props: The De La Cruz Show
Elly De La Cruz (-135) is the star attraction, with the Over 1.5 hits line. Why? Because he’s Elly De La Cruz, and he’s hitting .272 with 19 HRs. Also, keep an eye on Nolan Gorman (-150) for a stolen base — because nothing says “Cardinals” like a stolen base.

Wild Cards
- TJ Friedl (-140) Over 1.5 hits: A .376 OBP man, what else?
- Willson Contreras (+200) Over 0.5 HRs: A 12 HR man, but it’s a small sample, folks.
- Andrew Abbott (+150) to get the win: Because the Reds need someone to pitch.

Final Verdict
The Reds are 60% winners when favored by -152 or shorter this season, so they’ll likely scratch out a 5-4 win. But if you’re feeling lucky, back the Cardinals +127 and hope for a De La Cruz HR (+300). After all, nothing says “Cincinnati” like a 2.62 ERA and a .364 OBP.

Prediction: Reds 5, Cardinals 4. And yes, it’ll be boring.

More archived MLB props

Original social copy