Prop Bets: Tampa Bay Rays VS New York Yankees 2025-07-28

Yankees vs. Rays: A Food Fight in pinstriples
The New York Yankees (56-48) and Tampa Bay Rays (53-52) clash on July 28, 2025, in what’s essentially a food fight between two teams with zero self-control at the plate. The Yankees, third in MLB scoring (5.2 RPG), will face the Rays, who’ve crammed 487 runs this season (10th in MLB). Both teams are oddly priced at even moneyline odds (-110), because why not make this a coin flip? It’s baseball, not a math test!

The Pitcher’s Dilemma
Cam Schlittler (Yankees) vs. Drew Rasmussen (Rays)? Sounds like a battle of two pitchers who’ve both seen the inside of a strike zone. Schlittler’s over/under for strikeouts is 4.5 (betting line: -148 for over), while Rasmussen’s identical line (-130) suggests neither will dominate. Translation: Buckle up for a batting showcase.

Why the Rays Won’t Quit
Despite being underdogs, Tampa’s 42.9% winning percentage in underdog roles is better than your dating app success rate. Players like Yandy Diaz (+350 for over 0.5 doubles) and Junior Caminero (+330 for over 0.5 HRs) could turn this into a slap-and-dash rally. But let’s be real: Giancarlo Stanton (+280 for over 0.5 HRs) is the real villain here. He’s not hitting a home run—he’s declaring war on Rasmussen’s ERA.

The Prop Bet Playground
- Yandy Diaz’s Doubles: Bet the over (+350) if you enjoy watching a man turn singles into “I accidentally hit a wall, but it counts.”
- Giancarlo Stanton’s HR: Over 0.5 HRs (+280) is basically a guarantee. The only mystery is whether it’ll be a moonshot or a “I cleared the fence, but my momentum carried me into the next state.”
- Total Runs: Over 8.5 (-110) is a no-brainer. These teams combined for 9.1 runs per game last month—because July 2025 is just one big MLB spring training.

Final Verdict
The Yankees’ 56.2% win rate as favorites is about as reliable as a weather forecast in July. But with Schlittler and Rasmussen both looking like they’d rather be pitching in a hammock, this game hinges on who botches fewer pop-ups.

Prediction: Yankees 6, Rays 5 in 10 innings. The Rays will make you sweat, but the Yankees’ third-place offense will out-eat them. And yes, Anthony Volpe will get a hit. He always does.

Place your bets on the over and a Giancarlo Stanton HR. And maybe take the Rays just to spite the odds. July 28: Bring a snack. You’ll need it. 🍕⚾

More archived MLB props

Original social copy