Prop Bets: Washington Nationals VS St. Louis Cardinals 2025-07-09

Washington Nationals vs. St. Louis Cardinals: A Midsummer Night’s (Baseball) Dream
July 9, 2025 — St. Louis, MO

The Washington Nationals (37-54) are in St. Louis to face the Cardinals (49-43) in a game that’s basically a “pick ‘em with a side of desperation.” The Nationals, fresh off a managerial firing, are hoping their new skipper can work magic… or at least stop the team from looking like they’re batting left-handed with their eyes closed. The Cardinals, meanwhile, are trying to avoid a three-game series sweep after winning Game 1 4-2. Spoiler: They’ll probably fail.

The Odds, Straight Up
- Moneyline: Cardinals are a favorite so modest they could hide behind a bushel basket at -101. Nationals are +1600, which means if you bet $100 on Washington and they somehow win, you’d get $1,600. Statistically, that’s about as likely as MacKenzie Gore throwing a no-hitter while juggling pineapples.
- Spread: Cardinals -5.5 (-110) / Nationals +5.5 (-110). Given the Cardinals average 4.5 runs/game and the Nationals 4.4, this spread is basically the sportsbook saying, “We have no idea who’ll win, but let’s charge you to find out.”
- Total: 11.5 runs (Over: -115, Under: -115). With both teams’ pitchers looking like they’ve seen a ghost (Gore’s ERA: 4.72, Pallante’s: 4.33), this game could end up looking like a fireworks show.

Player Props to Bet On (Or Avoid)
- Alec Burleson (Cards): Over 1.5 hits at -110. He’s a .312 hitter in July, which means he’s either a robot or the Cardinals’ secret weapon. Go with Over.
- CJ Abrams (Nats): Over 1.5 hits at +120. Abrams is a .289 hitter, but with the Nationals’ offense, this is his best shot at stardom… or a cry for help.
- Nolan Arenado (Cards): Over 0.5 RBIs at +102. He’s technically a slugger, but with the Nationals’ pitching, even a pop fly might count.

The Verdict
The Cardinals should win this one, but not because they’re good. They’re just better at not being the Nationals. Washington’s 44.6% win rate as a -101+ underdog is about as reliable as a chair made of Jell-O. Pick the Cards, but bet the Nationals on a Hail Mary. And if you see Nathaniel Lowe go 5-for-5 with a triple, call your bookie… and a priest.

Final Score Prediction: Cardinals 7, Nationals 4. (But don’t @ me if it’s 12-11 Nats. I’ll have seen it all.) 🎩⚾

More archived MLB props

Original social copy